If you register, you can do a lot more. And become an active part of our growing community. You'll have access to hidden forums, and enjoy the ability of replying and starting conversations.

Mid Hants Railway Operational Matters

本贴由 NightRail 于 2017-01-11 发布. 版块名称: Heritage Railways & Centres in the UK

  1. jnc

    jnc Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2012-04-03
    帖子:
    1,881
    支持:
    3,245
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    Western Atlantic
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Exactly. Resources are finite; and TANSTAAFL.
     
  2. UP13

    UP13 New Member

    注册日期:
    2018-08-23
    帖子:
    109
    支持:
    146
    所在地:
    London
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Mate, you can have both steam and diesel. You can have both 1960s and 1990s...

    The science museum didn't chuck out the victorian stuff when they got the space stuff in...
     
  3. martin1656

    martin1656 Guest

    Will the 150 be used until the hampshire unit is done then duties shared with it, or is the plan to have it as a standby after that, to be reliable the unit will need to be used, The best use, will be if every now and then, the railways has a DMU running day, when its just the DMU's If the idea is to run a one deisel, ( DMU) and 1 steam service as the default offering, early, and late season, when its not finacially viable to have a second steam loco in traffic, that makes sence, then the deisel service could alternate between the two DMU's,
     
  4. jnc

    jnc Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2012-04-03
    帖子:
    1,881
    支持:
    3,245
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    Western Atlantic
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    They did have to expand their buildings to hold it all (see here), which obviously required money.
     
  5. 21B

    21B Part of the furniture

    注册日期:
    2009-09-02
    帖子:
    5,453
    支持:
    12,970
    Good heavens. We are talking about 150ft of siding space, in the last 20 years we have acquired about net about 50ft! The departures have more or less matched the arrivals, and we have 500ft more space than we used to have at least. (Ropley Top Yard).
     
    已获得cymroglan, UP13, Johnme101 和 另外1人的支持.
  6. goldfish

    goldfish Nat Pres stalwart

    注册日期:
    2009-01-13
    帖子:
    17,201
    支持:
    16,374
    Museums generally have disposal and deaccession policies to ensure they’re sustainable, reflecting the finite resources they have. And that’s without the same pressures heritage railways have to maintain working and financially viable railways.

    @green five ’s post with the MHR’s policy on use of the 150 is reassuring… ‘backup only’ makes similar sense to the Bluebell’s shift on ‘no diesels’, and so long as the thumper is available and reliable, it's potentially a win all around. 'Preservaation with purpose' makes far more sense to me than 'EVERYTHING MUST BE SAVED!'…

    Simon
     
    已获得green five、35B和Hampshire Unit的支持.
  7. Dunfanaghy Road

    Dunfanaghy Road Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2019-10-09
    帖子:
    1,580
    支持:
    2,128
    性别:
    男
    职业:
    Retired
    所在地:
    Alton, Hants
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    There's a few here should heed the wisdom of Oddball: "stop hitting me with those negative waves, Moriarty!"
    Pat
     
    已获得Glenmutchkin, cymroglan, green five 和 另外4人的支持.
  8. jnc

    jnc Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2012-04-03
    帖子:
    1,881
    支持:
    3,245
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    Western Atlantic
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Well, the 150 can live outside; it's not the issue. I suspect those of us who were voicing cautious notes were thinking more in general, in response to the 'save everything one can' note we heard from some posters (I certainly was). Look, e.g. at the massive shed the Bluebell built to hold un-restored stock. They did collect a lot of stuff - but they were willing to pay the very substantial cost of storing it properly.
     
  9. 21B

    21B Part of the furniture

    注册日期:
    2009-09-02
    帖子:
    5,453
    支持:
    12,970
    I find it deeply sad that a piece of good news has to be picked apart to such an extent that even I am left wondering why anyone bothers to try to the hard work of preserving any of our railway heritage. I think perhaps it’s time to stop reading National Preservation at all.
     
    已获得cymroglan的支持.
  10. 60044

    60044 Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2016-02-24
    帖子:
    1,746
    支持:
    2,364
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    Salisbury
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    If you have such an inability to accommodate the less positive views of others then perhaps your conclusion is right!
     
  11. 35B

    35B Nat Pres stalwart

    注册日期:
    2011-06-18
    帖子:
    33,311
    支持:
    36,949
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    Grantham
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    And therein lies an interesting tangent to the historical relevance of a 150 to a railway in Hampshire celebrating the former LSWR & SR. The 150 is the diesel twin of the class 455s that have provided commuter services on Herbert Walker’s electrification these last 40+ years. All of the objections (IMHO, railway heritage NIMBYism) raised to a 150 are doubled up with a 455 given their inability to work off the juice.

    I hope that, with the interpretation that comes with the 150, there will be some mention of the electric members of the MK3 multiple unit family.
     
    已获得Hampshire Unit的支持.
  12. DcB

    DcB Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2018-06-05
    帖子:
    1,578
    支持:
    508
    所在地:
    Surrey
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Many MK3 EMUs and DMUs are being scrapped.
    Not sure if this 150 is the only 150 to be preserved in working condition as an early train until the "Thumper" is repaired, then becomes a "backup" or runs at some Diesel galas?
    Think one MK3 Mersey line EMU and one 422 EMU driving car as part of a 125 train has been preserved.

    So far no firm preservation plans for the MK3 455 EMUs which are not so easy to run on preserved lines and keep in good order? One unit 455868 is in blue earmarked for preservation, but no one has offered to take it on
     
    Last edited: 2025-08-03
    已获得Hampshire Unit和35B的支持.
  13. Matt78

    Matt78 Well-Known Member

    注册日期:
    2007-06-27
    帖子:
    1,865
    支持:
    4,844
    职业:
    Solicitor
    所在地:
    South Wales
    This is an interesting debate and clearly not specific to the MHR.

    my own line has turned down the offer of a Pacer at least twice: we looked at it but there were a number of issues including compatibility with other stock in the event of failure, practicality and unsuitability to the sharper curves on our line.

    that said we did accept a HST power car which doesn’t have any obvious operational use but is certainly an important part of our local heritage.

    I expect that more 15xxxx units will enter preservation. How the second generation scene will evolve remains to be seen but as I think has been stated elsewhere in this forum the issue of keeping first generation diesels in use will become more problematic over time with residual life exhausted and availability of spares etc. New second generation entering preservation offers (for now) a fairly simple operational solution. I wouldn't mind betting that other lines will view things the same way.

    regards

    Matt
     
    已获得jnc, silversteellady, green five 和 另外3人的支持.
  14. martin1656

    martin1656 Guest

    I suppose a lot depends on what the purpose is, behind accepting the 150, It does give you an immediate way to have a better service from Alton, whilst the more historically accurate Hampshire unit is overhauled, but does historically accurate put bums on seats, put money in the coffers? For some no doubt it does, but for the greater market, any unit, even a to them modern unit, is better than having to wait till nearly mid day for a train, and of course the view out of the window will be the same, My own view is , I'm OK with it, but, if its a service thats intended to be deisel hauled, then show it as such in the timetable, with an explanation, as to what's likely to haul it, IE, the Southern Region classic Hampshire unit, or the train that replaced them, the second generation DMU,150,
     
    已获得MellishR, jnc, green five 和 另外1人的支持.
  15. Gladiator 5076

    Gladiator 5076 Resident of Nat Pres

    注册日期:
    2015-10-02
    帖子:
    10,212
    支持:
    8,622
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    Swanage
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    I also find it amusing that since this announcement it appears (at least from some of the posts on here) that first gen DMU's which were "unacceptable" when replacing steam due to coal costs, volunteer shortage etc are now seen as "good diesels" with the suggestion of the arrival of a 150.
    But then of course if you like BR Black, as some of us do we are some sort of weirdo to many.:D
     
    已获得jnc、Hampshire Unit和35B的支持.
  16. Swan Age

    Swan Age Member

    注册日期:
    2005-09-08
    帖子:
    966
    支持:
    306
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    21C101 in the South West
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    After hearing news of the 150 sprinter coming to the MHR, I have to say I welcome it.

    Having lived in Exeter for nearly 40 years i have observed these units have been running in the South West for many years and still regularly work ex LSWR routes to Barnstaple, Okehampton and Gunnislake as well as the wider South West and I have travelled on them regularly over the years.

    They are generally reliable, capable units and certainly won't be a problem on the MHR gradients. If they can get up to Gunnislake on the Bere Alston branch and the bank from Exeter St Davids to Exeter Central which is 1 in 37 I have no concerns.

    As for suitability to the MHR, well they have worked a lot of their lives on Ex. LSWR territory so they deserve a place in the story of Southern railway history.

    Looking forward to 150231 arriving at the MHR and I'll certainly look forward to a round trip on it.
     
    Last edited: 2025-08-03
    已获得MellishR, green five, CH 19 和 另外6人的支持.
  17. martin1656

    martin1656 Guest

    Is Porterbrook planning on donating any more 150's once off lease, Would one be accepted by the Swanage Railway if one were offered, plus already equipped with the various fittings, if operating to Wareham ever again raised it head, such a unit might be easier to operate than an 108
     
  18. Tintagel

    Tintagel New Member

    注册日期:
    2022-02-05
    帖子:
    55
    支持:
    100
    性别:
    男
    所在地:
    UK
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    I don't think it gets past the main issue with the Wareham service - it doesn't make economic sense.
     
  19. Cartman

    Cartman Part of the furniture Account Suspended

    注册日期:
    2015-12-14
    帖子:
    3,177
    支持:
    2,476
    性别:
    男
    职业:
    Van driver
    所在地:
    Cheshire
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    There's a really good photo of the 144 in a nice location on the KWVR and it does look good. As soon as an equally photogenic shot of the 150 on the Mid Hants turns up, people will start liking it.

    Me, I like a bit of a mixture, from pre grouping to privatisation, although very recent stuff doesn't interest me
     
  20. Hampshire Unit

    Hampshire Unit Well-Known Member Friend

    注册日期:
    2012-01-16
    帖子:
    1,645
    支持:
    3,724
    性别:
    男
    职业:
    Carer, Gardener
    所在地:
    Alresford
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    Indeed, having a Hampshire unit and a 150 just extends the DMU story that the Watercress Line can tell. From an operational point of view it allows for a reliable non-steam solution to moving people around, particularly from Alton, with its mainline connection, to Ropley where most educational exhibits are, or to Alresford for a non-railway tourist experience. Hammy will return, but if there is an economical way of keeping passenger numbers up until it is back in service, I don't mind that at all.
     
    Last edited: 2025-08-03
    已获得MellishR, green five, cymroglan 和 另外2人的支持.

分享此页面