If you register, you can do a lot more. And become an active part of our growing community. You'll have access to hidden forums, and enjoy the ability of replying and starting conversations.

Green Arrow

Discussion in 'Steam Traction' started by ssk2400, Aug 18, 2014.

  1. pmh_74

    pmh_74 Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2009
    Messages:
    2,217
    Likes Received:
    1,457
    As an engineer I've lost count of:
    a) the number of jobs abandoned half-done when the money ran out, and
    b) the number of jobs which went over budget, after the original engineering estimate was slashed by people not understanding the job

    The problem is that if all estimates were realistic AND included enough contingencies for everything which could go wrong, either
    A) no job would ever actually start at all, or
    B) some other firm would claim they could do it cheaper, and then sting you for variations later or deliver a half-done job

    It's not as easy as just saying "people need to be realistic with their estimates". But you can forgive any non-engineering types for being utterly bewhildered and frustrated by the lack of precision at the start.

    Credit where it's due for actually finishing Flying Scotsman, many organisations would have given up without finishing it, and if it had been some other lesser celebrity engine that's probably what would have happened. But I am not remotely surprised the NRM now seems reluctant to go down the same route again.
     
    acorb, Rosedale, 30854 and 9 others like this.
  2. guycarr360

    guycarr360 Part of the furniture

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2005
    Messages:
    4,414
    Likes Received:
    2,729
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Chester le Street County Durham
    What a great post, but this is so true in business, in any area.

    However the uncertainties that exist until complete dis-assembly are at the root of any estimate being wildly inaccurate, and then it is all over the floor of a contractor who maybe has offered the cheapest deal.

    Many times cheapest is not best, and comes home to roost on a regular basis.
     
    30854 and andrewshimmin like this.
  3. Bean-counter

    Bean-counter Part of the furniture

    Joined:
    Jul 21, 2007
    Messages:
    5,844
    Likes Received:
    7,688
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Former NP Member
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Which is why communication and respect of the differing expertise is so important between engineers and money men - and it certainly isn't a reason to 'not bother' with costing and scheduling work - having a time and money plan is perhaps even more important when things go wrong because it assists in making informed decisions about how to deal with the unexpected. The number of times I have been told 'we could get on with whatever if 'they' would let us spend £X' when I haven't even been aware of a problem or at least a potential solution and certainly not the potential cost and likely timing of the resultant output, while I have also suggested more than once spending extra money to achieve the desired output quicker only to be told 'I am not sure we could achieve that even with the extra expenditure, so I would rather not risk wasting the money'!

    All such discussions are best had when a previous, if now outdated, plan and budget exist.

    Steven
     
    Sawdust and 30854 like this.
  4. toplight

    toplight Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    May 18, 2009
    Messages:
    1,351
    Likes Received:
    1,288
    Location:
    Swindon, England
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    It is quite interesting watching this video made at Crewe works in 1936 where it follows a Jubilee locomotive being overhauled, and how exactly timed each section of the work was
    It was almost like an assembly line were, a gang would have a set time to do their part of the work, the chargehand would blow his whistle at the exact time and a crane would lift it to the next bay.
    The first gang would then start on the next loco and repeat the same on the next one



    Parts also had to be repaired and ready to refit at exact times so they were ready when needed

    The difficultly today in preservation is that everything is a one off with a small team having to do almost the entire loco, so if the first job is delayed it means job 2 starts late and then impacts job three etc
     
    30854 likes this.
  5. andrewshimmin

    andrewshimmin Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 18, 2011
    Messages:
    1,761
    Likes Received:
    2,160
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Amen, brother!
    My favourite half-finished job was a pipeline supplying water to a very large southern hemisphere city. Due to budget cuts, they built Package 1 (intake and first bit of pipeline) and Package 3 (reservoir and end bit of pipeline) but cancelled Package 2 (middle bit of pipeline)... But at least they didn't exceed the budget!
     
    30854 likes this.
  6. Sir Nigel Gresley

    Sir Nigel Gresley Member

    Joined:
    Nov 24, 2006
    Messages:
    880
    Likes Received:
    148
    Occupation:
    Retired Soldier of Fortune
    Location:
    Dorset

    The necessary outside steam pipes change the appearance of the front of the loco.

    It's quite apparent from all of the threads in this forum that nobody bothers to look at the plethora of books with historical photos and other details!
     
    The Green Howards likes this.
  7. Miff

    Miff Part of the furniture Friend

    Joined:
    Jun 17, 2008
    Messages:
    2,857
    Likes Received:
    2,793
    Judith started her career working in engineering, including starting a machine tool company in her 20s, and moving on to work with a venture capitalist in the engineering sector where she led a diverse range of companies. So says the Science Museum website.
     
    Rosedale likes this.
  8. 30854

    30854 Resident of Nat Pres

    Joined:
    Mar 8, 2017
    Messages:
    12,172
    Likes Received:
    11,493
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Retired
    Location:
    Brighton&Hove
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    What a great clip. Boiling caustic soda, exposed asbestos wool and ne'er a hard hat to be seen. The 'move loco' whistle blast from the foreman is much shorter than the traditional 'all OUT' whistle from the Shop Steward!

    With the discussion elsewhere about mileages between ovehaul, the given LMS figure of 120-150,00 miles is noteworthy, though I doubt the figure was that high for many of the inherited pre-grouping designs (cough.... Derby bearings).

    When you realise many restoration projects have less active members with grubby hands than the LMS had to re-fit coupling rods, you begin to understand why the process can take so long.

    If Swindon had anything like that "Colourdex" system, I'd love to know just how the 'scrap and build' trick with VoR 1213 was pulled off!!
     
  9. Spamcan81

    Spamcan81 Nat Pres stalwart

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 2007
    Messages:
    35,121
    Likes Received:
    20,773
    Occupation:
    Training moles
    Location:
    The back of beyond
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    I trust those who doubted her engineering expertise will now post an apology. Not that I'm holding my breath.
     
  10. W.Williams

    W.Williams Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2015
    Messages:
    1,585
    Likes Received:
    1,465
    Occupation:
    Mechanical Engineer
    Location:
    Aberdeenshire
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    Yes I am an active volunteer
    If it were me, after handing over a finished set of drawings I would expect quotes for a fully finish machined, with liners installed, 3 part assembly (no more monoblock) for under 200k. So you could probably say new cylinders for no more than 350k??? I would really hope so anyway!!

    However, the drawings themselves would need to be brought up to modern standards and some cad models supplied, so that's going to be at least a couple grand more on top. Want to model the whole V2 in cad, that's a serious task, maybe a month or more of work. Outside clients looking to utilize company design engineers are usually quoted flat rates of around 500 quid a day. I of course see nothing like that in my pocket.

    There is also the potential that you make a new cylinder assembly and the frames have deviations in hole placement. Bye bye budget. Its easy to make something to a drawing and have it dimensioned right, but is it going to fit this bespoke machine??

    But that's not the real issue. Its the potential can of worms you open up when you take out the old monoblock and strip the engine back that is going to be a budget killer.


    Indeed, an impressive resume for someone who is running a museum. And to play the gender card, even more so that this individual is a woman! Not that that matters, passion is far more important.

    EDIT. Pulled from the NRM page. For anyone questioning her credentials, I suggest you keep it to yourself if you ever want to see a V2 in action, as this is one of the stakeholders you have to convince.

    Judith McNicol
    Museum Director
    [​IMG]
    Judith has been part of the Science Museum Group for 13 years, based at the National Railway Museum. She has held many roles supporting both the National Railway Museum and the wider group, most recently as Director of People and Culture.

    The National Railway Museum is close to her heart; her great-great-grandfather was one of many to die in the building of the Forth railway bridge. She remembers travelling across the bridge from a young age, in awe of its scale, beauty and the possibilities it embodied. Joining the National Railway Museum to work amongst the great ‘firsts’—Stephenson, Brunel, Mallard, Rocket and of course Flying Scotsman—was a childhood dream come true.
     
    Last edited: Aug 26, 2017
  11. Bean-counter

    Bean-counter Part of the furniture

    Joined:
    Jul 21, 2007
    Messages:
    5,844
    Likes Received:
    7,688
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Former NP Member
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Making one cylinder, using modern pattern making techniques and a computer scan of the old cylinder to make sure the fitting bolts are put in the right place, would be considerably less than £100k, so a new monoblock should, on that basis, come in at under £200k and arguably even under £150k or possibly less depending on the 'breakdown' of costs - certainly, pattern and even casting materials will only be a proportion of overall cost and scanning and machining could well be less than 3 times the cost of a single cylinder once the block is set up on the scanner/lathe. Whether there would be a premium for making such a large single casting may be an issue, but I inclined to feel that it won't be that large for those who make such things - power stations, large ships etc. could all feature large castings, although they may be fabricated these days.

    In theory, fabricating a cylinder is cheaper but it is prone to fatal distortions during the lengthy fabrication process.

    Nut. hey, I am only a 'bean-counter', so could well have the whole thing wrong! ;)

    Steven
     
  12. paullad1984

    paullad1984 Member

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2007
    Messages:
    918
    Likes Received:
    428
    Has anyone actually volunteered the cash to give her a rebuild.....?
     
  13. MellishR

    MellishR Resident of Nat Pres Friend

    Joined:
    Apr 16, 2009
    Messages:
    8,069
    Likes Received:
    5,165
    Regardless of whether replacement cylinders are made in one piece or three, they could still have the same arrangement of steam pipes as the original, if the consensus is to prefer that rather than the way it was done before for three separate cylinders.

    You'd have to be very rich indeed or very foolish to offer a blank cheque. And offering £X thousand wouldn't be much good if the repair looks like costing £3X thousand. The starting point would have to be agreement in principle by the NRM to whatever is proposed (most promisingly making new cylinders in some form by some means and putting the old block on display) and a ballpark figure for the amount of cash likely to be needed.
     
  14. paullad1984

    paullad1984 Member

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2007
    Messages:
    918
    Likes Received:
    428
    I was just thinking we've had all this discussion but no one's actually offered.....
     
  15. Miff

    Miff Part of the furniture Friend

    Joined:
    Jun 17, 2008
    Messages:
    2,857
    Likes Received:
    2,793
    This 2014 post by @Anthony Coulls of the NRM says "When the V2 was preserved, locos were selected because they were the first/oldest/most original survivor of their class. Green Arrow was available so was selected. The single casting cylinders were significant but not the be all and end all. We don't know that they aren't repairable - there would need to be a survey with the loco dismantled, but it's not the Arrow's time at present."
    https://www.national-preservation.com/threads/green-arrow.332507/page-2#post-934865
     
  16. 30854

    30854 Resident of Nat Pres

    Joined:
    Mar 8, 2017
    Messages:
    12,172
    Likes Received:
    11,493
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Retired
    Location:
    Brighton&Hove
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    Interesting that Blodge are going the other way with their Fairlie bogies. AIUI, the reason being steam tightness over an extended working period.

    Quite what this says about how far monobloc design has come since the V2 was designed, I don't know.
     
    paullad1984 likes this.
  17. Allegheny

    Allegheny Member

    Joined:
    May 8, 2015
    Messages:
    625
    Likes Received:
    308
    Gender:
    Male
    Heritage Railway Volunteer:
    No I do not currently volunteer
    I'm guilty of re-starting this thread. See post #30, 6 pages ago
     

Share This Page